Anatolian Shepherd vs Kangal: Understanding Two Powerful Turkish Guardians
The debate continues today about whether the Anatolian Shepherd and Kangal are identical or different breeds, and this article will help spot the right answer away from common misconceptions. Many people believe these two dog breeds are the same, but when you shine a light on their differences, the truth becomes clear upon careful examination. Having worked with both breeds during my years in rural Turkey, I can tell you that while these extremely protective guard dogs share a lineage dating back to the Bronze Age, one makes a fantastic family companion while the other is better suited for serious livestock guardian work.
The Turkish origin connects these powerful protectors of the land. Still, their muscular, impressive presence serves different purposes – Anatolians have gained popularity among first-time owners despite their headstrong nature. At the same time, true Kangal shepherds remain dedicated to protecting flocks from wolves, buffalo, and even cheetahs on farms.
Choose the best fit for your lifestyle by understanding their similarities and key distinctions, as both possess a sharp mind and an independent personality that can metaphorically and physically walk over an unprepared owner. These massive physique dogs were bred for following and protecting animals and humans across harsh Turkish terrain, making them suited for guard duties but requiring experienced handling.
When you compare and contrast these magnificent breeds, you’ll learn that both protect their territory with unwavering dedication, yet one makes a more adaptable family guardian while the other excels as a specialized livestock protector. The difference becomes apparent once you decide to look beyond surface appearances and understand their distinct breeding purposes and temperaments.
Photo credit: Freepik by EyeEm
Anatolian Shepherd vs Kangal: Purebred Status and History
Much debate exists regarding the purebred status of the Anatolian shepherd and Kangal, with different international governing bodies taking varying positions on whether these are separate breeds. The AKC recognizes Anatolian shepherds as their own breed but do not acknowledge Kangals separately, while the UKC consider Kangals as an individual breed distinct from Anatolians. Studies show these dogs are indeed specific breeds with evident differences when compared, though their physical description remains extremely similar with some subtle differences we’ll touch on more later. Having worked with both breeds in Turkey, I’ve observed the most interesting difference between these two dog breeds lies in how they’re prized by residents of Turkey – Kangals are considered exclusively from a particular region, while Anatolians are bred more broadly across the country.
The Turkish dogs have existed for over 6,000 years, originally developed for hunting in Mesopotamia around 3 thousand years ago, then specifically adapted to the particular demands of Turkish climate extremes with both heat and cold. These nomadic societies needed dogs with exceptional stamina for guarding sheep across the vast Anatolian Plateau for centuries, making them perfectly suited to their exclusive region.
The breeds didn’t make their entry into the Western world until the middle of the 20th century, when American and British ranchers began importing these shepherding dogs around 1950. In 1968, archaeologist Charmian Hussey brought several to the U.K. for the purpose of breeding and raising them as family pets, while the Karabash Dog Club was founded in 1970 after U.S. Navy Lieutenant Robert Ballard brought a number of these dogs to the United States.
Speaking from experience with kangal dogs, they are found to be slightly larger than the ones called Anatolians, and are often faster as well, with a coat that’s shorter and less dense. The UK Kennel Club agreed to recognize Kangals separately in July 2013, but stated that dogs currently registered as Anatolians may be eligible to be recorded as Kangals instead. Similarly, in January 2012, the Australian National Kennel Council no longer recognized them as the same breed, and in June 2018, the Federation CynoLogique Internationale (FCI) Standards Commission determined that the majority of the FCI-registered Anatolian population actually belonged to the Kangal population. The FCI name was changed and the standard content updated, while the American Kangal Club continues to advocate for separate recognition, believing the differences are significant enough on a genetic level to warrant classification as different breeds – though many dog lovers like myself believe the distinction comes down to size, build, and regional origin rather than fundamental genetic variation.
Key Differences Between Anatolian Shepherd vs Kangal
While there are few subtle differences between Anatolian shepherds and Kangal dogs, the primary difference lies in their purebred status and recognition as individual breeds – many people claim they are the same, but having spent time with families who live in the Kangal district of Turkey, I can tell you they recognize the Kangal as a separate breed with distinct characteristics. After studying both breeds closely, some key distinctions emerge in their temperaments, physical appearances, and lifespans that we’ll talk about in more detail now – the Kangal tends to be slightly more reserved and focused compared to the Anatolian shepherd’s broader temperament range, while physical differences include the Kangal’s typically shorter coat and more compact build, though both breeds share similar lifespans and working capabilities as livestock guardians.
Photo credit: Shutterstock by zhukovvvlad
Anatolian Shepherd vs Kangal: Physical Appearance
When comparing the physical differences between Anatolian Shepherd and Kangal dogs, both appear similar enough that they’re often mistaken for the same breed, though the Kangal is usually larger and weighs more than the shepherd. The size and weight difference usually amounts to an inch or few pounds, making the difference extremely subtle but significant to those who live in Turkey where these dogs are prized for specific colors and appearances that must be met in order to be considered purebred.
Kangal’s, for the most part, are found in a wide variety of brown shades with very specific facial colorings, while Anatolians come in lighter shades and far more common buff tones, occasionally with black masked ears. The coat texture is different too – Kangals have fur around the neck that’s longer than their general short coats, while Anatolians sport coarse top hair over a luxurious undercoat that feels thick and muscular from bottom to top.
The first thing you’ll notice when these dogs enter a room is you need to make sure you have space – we’re talking about big dogs like a black Lab times two, with an 80-pound dog being on the small side for this kind of breed. A full-grown male can weigh between 110 to 150 pounds of pure muscle, with typical males measuring out at 29 inches tall at the shoulder – though I’ve seen examples of Anatolians getting much larger, with the largest on record topped at a whopping 40 inches tall. Female dogs can reach staggering weights of 120 pounds, and in addition to their thick, muscular build, their hair covers a lush undercoat – this combination serves to give them an even thicker appearance and look heavier than they actually are.
Anatolian Shepherd vs Kangal: Lifespan
Another potential difference between the Anatolian shepherd and Kangal is their life span – both are large yet extremely healthy breeds that typically live over 10 years, however, Kangals may outlive Anatolian shepherds slightly with an average lifespan of 12-15 years compared to the shepherd’s 10-13 years, depending on the level of care provided. Again, this is a subtle difference but worth mentioning since many people prefer the Kangal for this reason, and I don’t blame them given the dog’s rarity and the fact that Kangal puppies tend to cost more overall – it’s something to keep in mind if you want to bring one of these magnificent guardians into your home for the long haul.
Anatolian Shepherd vs Kangal: Temperament
The final difference between the Anatolian shepherd and Kangal lies in their temperaments – both dogs were bred for hard work and protection, but the Kangal is largely considered better with people compared to the Anatolian, though this isn’t to say either breed is particularly friendly in the conventional sense.
Their independence has been simply observed more in Anatolians, while Kangal’s show slightly more willingness to engage with family members. Like all large breeds, both need ample exercise and good nutrition, and are likely to enjoy spending time with many members of the family – the Kangal enjoys the company of its master but tends to be too busy protecting the land otherwise. If you’re a first-time dog owner going to get your first guardian breed, I’d look elsewhere since the Anatolian’s independent nature means they’re best suited for experienced handlers.
For literally thousands of years, Anatolians were trained to keep track of flocks for nomadic tribes wandering the plains and deserts, making them smart enough to pick up instructions and training very quickly. Speak to them and they will understand what you want – whether or not they choose to obey will come down to their mood and absolutely none of them are aloof in the sense that one doesn’t form bonds. Quite the opposite – whereas most dogs see humans as companions or pack leaders, these breeds see you in a different light than typical owners and families. You aren’t their pack leader – you’re part of their flock, according to Dogs International. Rather than someone to be implicitly listened to and obeyed, they view you as something to be looked after.
Because of this love and devotion, they can be slow to adjust to all strangers and even close friends who do not live in your home may have a time getting the dogs warm to them, even with repeated home visits. For this exact reason, early socialization and obedience training are imperative – you can never go wrong enrolling your puppy into kindergarten classes. Teaching them that not all unfamiliar situations are scary is an important part of having these magnificent protectors as family companions.
Photo credit: Shutterstock by FOTMA
Living Needs
Both Anatolian and Kangal dogs need lots of room to thrive – apartment living is out of the question for any guardian breed, and a yard without a fence is pretty much a non-starter since they’re too big and have herding instincts with tons of stamina. These dogs are also built more for endurance than bursts of speed, so they don’t require as much exercise daily as you might imagine – a half-hour walk every day should be plenty, plus a game of fetch in the backyard when possible. As Choczynski Johnson says, they’re incredibly independent, so leaving them unattended at home alone while you go to work doesn’t tend to be a problem since they don’t suffer from separation anxiety as badly as other breeds.
Anatolians can do well with other dogs, though it helps to begin socializing puppies early – I always recommends scheduling puppy playdates to help your dog get accustomed to others from a young age, as this prevents territorial issues later in life and makes them more adaptable to various living situations.
Bonus: Which Dog Has the Strongest Bite Force in the World?
Bred to protect livestock from wolves, bears, and other large predators, the Turkish Kangal is a giant dog with a fearsome bite force of 743 PSI – more powerful than any other breed and even stronger than a lion’s bite. These dogs aren’t in the business of herding but serious protection work, trained from an early age where puppies are left alone with lambs to become accustomed to their smell, and around five months old they’re exposed to wolf pelt to learn to recognize this terrible foe. Once they start their work, Kangal’s are fitted with spiked collars around their necks during inevitable battles with predators, making them incredibly dependable guardians that require no supervision to live and do their jobs to the best of their abilities – I’ve witnessed firsthand how these magnificent dogs can single-handedly defend entire flocks against multiple wolves, showcasing why they’ve earned their reputation as the ultimate livestock guardian.
Conclusion
Though they look similar when comparing the Anatolian Shepherd and Kangal, the Kangal tends to be more gentle of the two and calmer as a peaceful dog around family and children, while Anatolian Shepherds may be easier to find in the U.S. because Kangal’s aren’t typically allowed to be exported from Turkey. If you have many acres of livestock to protect and are looking for a guardian that lives to serve your home and property, then both breeds will make great guardians – from my experience working with these magnificent dogs, either choice will provide you with a loyal, dedicated protector that has been perfecting the art of livestock guardianship for thousands of years.
